Hi Michael. Sorry you’re having this issue.
From the screenshot you sent, it looks like you have a customization in place because my version doesn’t have that “hide recurring instances” checkbox anywhere (visible in your screenshot next to “All SEO Scores”)
There might be some new updates available. Could you please make sure all your Modern Tribe plugins (and WordPress core) are at their latest versions?
Once you verify you’re on the latest versions, please test to see if the issue is still happening for you.
If it is, please follow our Testing for Conflicts Guide and see if that helps narrow down the cause of this.
If it doesn’t, please share your System Information. That will give me a lot of extra information to help diagnose the problem.
Let us know what you find out.
Thanks.