Hi Cory. Thanks for your Eventbrite purchase and interest in our Event Tickets Plus product.
Regarding Eventbrite, when the plugin’s active, you should see these settings: http://cl.ly/3o3T1k1p1w1y
As far as a “swap” goes, we cannot do that. However, you can submit a Refund Request for your Eventbrite purchase and then just do a new purchase for Event Tickets Plus.
Whether or not you should use Eventbrite or Event Tickets Plus is of course a personal decision, but buying and trying Event Tickets Plus may make the decision clear for you.
Let me know if you have any follow-up questions.