Hi, Nick.
I’m sorry but I’m not fully understanding the situation you’re describing.
Regardless, I see you’re not on the latest versions of our plugins.
Could you please make sure all your Modern Tribe plugins (and WordPress core) are at their latest versions?
Once you verify you’re on the latest versions, please test to see if the issue is still happening for you.
If it is, please share step-by-step instructions for me to try to recreate this issue.
If you share an annotated screenshot or video screen capture, it might help communicate what you’re seeing and what exactly the issue is.