Hey Matt,
Welcome back to the forums and sorry to hear about the issue. I just tried replicating the issue on my local test environment using the latest version of WP, our plugins and the default Twenty Sixteen theme. I was able to navigate to the correct recurring event date rather than being taken to the “All” page.
I also took a look at our logged bugs report and don’t see anything in there with similar traits. With all that said, can you please confirm you’ve ran through our Testing for conflicts to ensure you’re not experiencing a theme and/or plugin conflict. I see you checked “Yes” for both of those, but I just like to double-check.
Let me know and we’ll go from there. Thanks for choosing PRO and enjoy your day.