Hey Marcy,
Welcome back! Based on what you’ve described, I believe you’re experiencing a known bug which is being addressed in the next maintenance release (should be out any hour/day now!) For the time being, we recommend downgrading to versions 4.1.3. You can get previous versions of PRO from your Downloads page and TEC here. You’ll need to do the updates manually.
I’ve attached this thread to the logged bug for the developers to reference. Hang tight and keep an eye on your WP plugin updates and theeventscalendar.com/blog for release info. Thanks for the patience and our apologies you’re having to deal with this bug.
Cheers!