Howdy Matt,
I would love to help you with this.
That is basically how recurring events are designed to work. 🙁 That’s why we have that little popup when you add a ticket to a recurring event that says there will only be one ticket available for the entire series of events. This is ideal for course style events, where one ticket gets you access to all recurrences, but obviously insufficient for other usages.
We are certainly not oblivious to the limitation and are working to add in the ability for each recurrence to have a separate ticket. But until then we are trying to be very up front in our advertising and popups letting people know about the limitation.
I really wish I had better news here. The one bit of good news I have is that this is a feature we have been working to build for a few months and will likely be ready by version 4.3 if not before.
Does that all make sense and answer your question? Please let me know.
Cheers!
– Brook