Hi Ryan. Thanks for the detailed information.
What do you have set at wp-admin > Settings > General > Timezone?
Whatever it’s set to, such as a UTC offset (like UTC-6 or UTC+3), you might want to try switching it to the appropriate city name (such as New York or Berlin, not that these match those UTC offset examples).
Then, please re-save the event in question (the one you provided a screenshot of) and also try creating a new event.
If you’re still having the issue, please provide a screenshot of your wp-admin Timezone settingsĀ and also a link to view the event you provided a screenshot for.
Thank you.