Hello melbournedigital,
Thanks for reaching out!
I think I understand what you are trying to achieve here, however I’m not familiar with the content restriction plugin you are using, and how it is set up.
If you can give me a rundown on how that plugin works and how the restrictions are set up, accompanied by screenshots, I might be able to help you.
Cheers,
Andras
A sidenote, I see you are using the plugin called Updater, which does “Automatically check and update WordPress website core with all installed plugins and themes to the latest versions.”
While this might look like a good feature and can save you some work, if by any chance a plugin update contains a bug – yes, it can happen, despite the best efforts of every developer – then the website might crash automatically.
To our users we recommend using a staging site to test the changes before updating the plugins on a live site.