Hi Travis,
Thanks so much for reaching out!
Unfortunately we cannot log in to your site per ourĀ Support Policy, but I will do my best to assist you here.
At this time, recurring events are not currently supported by Event Tickets Plus, which may be why you are having an issue with this setup.
You can also vote on this idea in our Feature Requests, as we tend to implement ideas based on customer feedback, so your input is greatly appreciated:
https://tribe.uservoice.com/forums/195723-feature-ideas/suggestions/3685663-recurring-event-support-for-tickets
You can include the Day 2 information in the Details portion or somewhere else, so that the price from Day 1 is added to the cart instead of Day 2.
Let me know if that helps!
Thanks,
Jaime