tonypantello,
Thanks for getting in touch! There a couple of things you might want to try to get the plugin to match your theme’s aesthetic.
First, try going to ‘Events->Settings->Display’ and changing the ‘Events Template’ to ‘Default Page Template’. This will force the plugin to use your theme’s page layout, and should hopefully match things a bit better.
Secondly, go to ‘Events->Settings->Display’ and change your styles to ‘Full styles’ (screenshot). This mode should try to grab CSS rules from your theme to match where possible.
Give those options a try and see if they help at all. Thanks! 🙂
-Casey-