Howdy weebi,
I am really glad you like the plugin. We do our best, and it is good to get feedback like this.
There are two ways for a theme to do paging in a theme, a simple way and a complicated one. Unfortunately, some themes go the complicated route which has numerous drawbacks, including conflicting with our plugin. It looks like your theme is going the complicated route. We have an article written up on how to write a proper paging function that you will likely find very interesting. It includes an example of the wrong way, and shows how to change it to the right one.
However, that tutorial will likely require some PHP knowledge to apply to your theme. If that is your cup of tea, you might need to hire a developer. We do keep a handy list of knowledgeable ones, and you can easily obtain it by emailing [email protected] and requesting.
Will that work for you? Does it all makes sense? Please let me know. Cheers!
– Brook