Hi @hydeaway!
Generally, regardless of the theme, you will always be able to pick between the Default Page Template and Default Events Template with that setting.
Beyond that, what you can pick from really depends on how the theme is coded and structured — if it exposes more than one page template, it should be listed there but that can’t be guaranteed and it varies by theme (really, it’s not a matter of the theme’s page templates being visible to our plugin, but of them being visible to WordPress itself).
With that said, if you are at home writing code and are feeling ambitious you could customize the list of available templates using a strategy like this one:
function modify_template_selector_list( $templates ) {
// Add any extra templates you want to pick from
// here then return the modified list
return $templates;
}
function setup_extra_event_templates( $no_modify ) {
add_filter( 'theme_page_templates', 'modify_template_selector_list' );
return $no_modify;
}
add_filter( 'tribe_display_settings_tab_fields', 'setup_extra_event_templates', 5 );
That’s just a starting point that you can use if you wish (and if you’re comfortable), there are a number of gaps you’d need to fill in that I can’t supply as I’m unfamiliar with your theme — but I hope if nothing else this provides an explanation of why and how it works 🙂