Hi Kevin,
Sorry to hear you’re facing difficulties.
On occasion we’ve found some themes don’t actually use the “native” main blog post loop facilitated by WordPress and roll their own based on a custom query. While I don’t know if that’s what is happening here it certainly seems like a case where it would be well worth following through the following troubleshooting steps:
- Please ensure all of your Modern Tribe plugins are up-to-date
- Deactivate all other plugins
- If you’ve been using a caching plugin please do take the time to read the plugin documentation on completing removing caching
- Switch to a default, unmodified theme like Twenty Twelve
- Does the problem still occur?
Assuming that solves the problem, though of course there is a chance it may not, please reactivate everything one-at-a-time, testing each time you reactivate something to try and determine what might be causing the conflict.
Does that help at all?