Hi Tyler!
Thanks for getting in touch with us! Let me help you with this topic.
I don’t think you are doing anything wrong here, it’s just how recurring events are designed to work. Let me explain this further and the way to achieve exactly what you are looking for.
The main event is the one you created for Jan 11 at 10am – 10.30am. All the recurring instances you created (both at the same time and from 10.30 to 11am) are weekly, which means they will be created starting next week Jan 18.
So, if you also want to add another instance for Jan 11 at 10.30am you can create a Once instance for that purpose. See the following event series as an example:
I hope that helps! Let me know if you have any follow up questions.
Best,
Victor