Hi there @atoohill,
Thanks for getting in touch with us and sorry to hear about this issue ๐
I wasn’t able to reproduce it in my local install, as you would expect the events are loading under the calendar once you click on a particular day.
Can you try to disable Events Calendar PRO as well, and use default theme Tweenty Sixteen? If the issue still persists in these conditions please try re-installing The Events Calendar (just delete the plugin from the ‘wp-content/plugins/’ folder, re-download the latest zip and place it there) no data will be lost as it’s stored in the database and not in the actual plugin folder.
If none of the above works please send me a database dump of the site and I’ll try to import it to my own test site and see if I can reproduce the issue.
Please let me know about it,
Best,
Nico