Good evening Carly and welcome back!
I’m sorry to hear that my previous suggestion of plugin did not help.
When you say it’s not working, could you give me some details ?
- Did you have a hard time configuring the plugin ?
- Did you use it’s test feature ?
- Is it only not working for Hotmail accounts ?
- Have you tried using different types of email accounts while using this setup (Gmail, personal, etc..)
A couple of other ideas would be to add SPF records to the email account you are using to send the emails (you might want to see with your webhost how to go about this).
Could you also tell me which webhost you are using ?
Have a good week-end,
Geoff B.