Hey Corey. Thanks for the details. Hopefully I can help you resolve your issue quickly.
You can access all of the latest versions of our plugins at My Account > Downloads.
At this time, The Events Calendar (core) is at v3.12.13 and the PRO add-on is at v3.12.2.
Please make sure you DO have the current versions of all our plugins.
Once you have the latest, greatest versions on your site, please test again. If you’re still having the issue, please copy your system information and paste it here. Make sure to use the “Set as private reply” checkbox to protect your private information from the public.
You can find the system info by going to WP Admin > Events > Settings, clicking on the “Help” tab, and scrolling down to the “System Information” box. (Or by going to [yoursite]/wp-admin/edit.php?post_type=tribe_events&page=tribe-events-calendar&tab=help)
That will give me a lot of extra information to help diagnose the problem.
I hope updating to the latest versions solves it for you, but, if not, having your system information will help a lot in finding a solution.
Thanks!