Hi Eric,
The Eventbrite add-on doesn’t have anything that would recognize members vs non-members. It strictly ports information to/from Eventbrite. Any membership management would have to be done on the WordPress side, and our add-on doesn’t add that on. 🙂
I’m not certain, but perhaps you’d want to look at the Easy Digital Downloads tickets and that ecosystem of extensions. I believe they have ways to distinguish between members and non-members, but I can’t say that I’m familiar with the specifics.
Sorry we don’t have a solution for you at the present time.
— Julie