Hello jaredtyson,
Thanks for reaching out to us!
The date for the single event is set using the “tribe_events_event_schedule_details” function found within the template-tags -> general.php file of the core plugin. Within that function you can see a filter at the bottom with the same name. Using this filter, you can add a custom function within your theme’s “functions.php” file to modify the way the date is output.
For this example, you can leave most of the function the same but just modify the “tribe_event_is_multiday” section to include the year after the second date of the event while leaving the setting within your dashboard set to “F j”.
Let me know if this helps.
Thanks!