Howdy fiberartnow,
Oh no. Let’s see what we can do to troubleshoot.
The first thing would be to make sure you are receiving any WP Emails. Go to WP Admin > Settings > Discussion and check “E-mail me whenever “E-mail me whenever Anyone Post a Comment”. Now try creating a subscriber account, and posting a comment. Do you get a notification?
When you go to WP Admin > Events > Settings > Community, could you copy/paste everything inside of the “Email addresses to be notified” box into a Private Reply here?
Please let me know if I can clarify anything or be of further assistance in the troubleshooting process. Cheers!
– Brook