Howdy jareddegnan,
I am sad to give you this news, but at least out of the box it looks like your theme is not fully compatible with Tribe Events. You should definitely try going to WP Admin > Events > Settings > Display, and trying out different Stylesheets, and perhaps templates as well. One of them might work.
However, I would not be surprised if they all show the spinner. Your theme is a bit “specifically broad” (how is that for a strange contradiction) with some of its CSS rules, to the point that it overrides Tribe CSS. If you are CSS savvy you can definitely create a child theme, and with a some minor CSS tweaks make the two compatible. If you are unable to do so and do not know someone whom you can hire, have no fear. We actually keep a list of freelancers who are quite capable of making changes on your behalf. You can obtain this list by emailing [email protected] and requesting it.
Does that make sense? Will that work for you? Please let me know. Cheers!
– Brook