Thanks. Jetpack seems to have done the trick.
But I also noticed that if I do enable sharing I cannot add my events via Google Calendar. Every event I have created, when I click on +Google Calendar it comes up as “Invalid Request”. I’ve tested it a few times, and it seems like I can’t add sharing AND have +Google Calendar at the same time. I’d like the ability to share events AND export to Google Calendar.
On my events page (anccbellevue.org/events) I have currently kept Jetpack ON so you can see what I am talking about when it comes to the “Invalid Request”.